Warning: Declaration of Portfolio_Walker::start_el(&$output, $category, $depth, $args) should be compatible with Walker_Category::start_el(&$output, $category, $depth = 0, $args = Array, $id = 0) in /nfs/c05/h04/mnt/82747/domains/papercutny.com/html/wp-content/themes/classica/functions.php on line 382
How to Make Homemade Butter! | Papercut / design for web, mobile and branding

The Blog

How to Make Homemade Butter!

Tis’ the season to go that little extra mile for the holidays or at least let them think you went the added mile.  There isn’t anything in the world like fresh homemade butter and this is easy even for the smallest of kitchens. This time around, I made a large batch with two pints of cream, which filled 3  1/2 pint Ball jars. I originally tried to pour both bottles into the food processor but that ended up being a huge fail. Just do one bottle at a time and avoid the mess I made.

At the end, I only added flake salt to flavour it, but in the past, I’ve used garlic or cinnamon and brown sugar to make butter gifts. Just make sure you add them while it’s still soft. Oh, btw, all that liquid left over is tasty buttermilk. We normally use this to make pancakes or rosemary garlic biscuits that are softer than Johnny Depp’s hair.

This is an adaptation from this recipe on LiveJournal: http://community.livejournal.com/food_porn/4909841.html

The final buttery product!

Easy Homemade Creamery Butter

Active Time: 20 min / Makes: .75 lb
2 cups (1 pint) heavy cream (I used Ronnybrook Farm Dairy’s)
kosher salt

Pour 2 cups of heavy cream in your food processor. The fresher the cream, the better the butter will turn out.  Pop the lid on, blitz, sit back and watch.

The cream will go through different stages. First you see it turning into a soft, silky whipped cream. A little later it’s turning into a really firm cream.

Then you hear a ‘slosh‘ and the grainy, yellow butter has separated itself from, what is now, nothing but buttermilk. SCORE!

All that’s left to do is drain the buttermilk and there you have it. Butter. If you are going to use it all up, you’re good to go now. If you want to keep the butter longer, you’ll have to rinse the butter curds with cold water.  Press it down with a spoon and stir it to get the excess liquid out.

Add salt, pepper, garlic or whatever spices you want to use to make your butter special.

We used our Swedish flake salt called Falk Salt: www.falksalt.com/. We actually bought ours in Sweden at a large grocery store but you can now buy it in the US. For those of you who can read Swedish: www.falksalt.se/

Get yourself some crunchy bread or your favorite carb (muffin, bagel, etc)  slice it, spread some of this delicious butter on top and revel in the good fat. Photos below but check out the set on Flickr. So, have y’all ever made butter? What flavourings have you added to the goodness?

2 Pints of Heavy Cream & a Food Processor

Add the unpasteurized cream to the food processor

Let it spin for 5 - 8 minutes

First it becomes whipped cream

Middle stage between whipped cream & butter

Then it separates out into yellow butter solids & buttermilk

Spoon it out into a bowl

Using a wooden spoon or spatula squeeze extra buttermilk out of the butter

Mix in salt, grated garlic or any other seasonings

The final buttery product!

Warning: count(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /nfs/c05/h04/mnt/82747/domains/papercutny.com/html/wp-includes/class-wp-comment-query.php on line 405


Got something to say? Feel free, I want to hear from you! Leave a Comment

  1. Stephanie says:

    this is great! i’m in the gift making crunch, where i’ve suddenly realized that all of the little things that i’ve been making aren’t quite enough for my gifting needs… plus, homemade butter? YUM!

  2. Matthew Mohr says:

    Very cool! My kid will think I’m a magician. Thanks!

  3. Tricia says: (Author)

    Y’all are entirely welcome! It’s a good simple recipe that even your kids would be able to master, Matthew. Oddly enough, my boyfriend, also named Matthew, used to do this by shaking when he was kid. And, his mum was all into that historical living stuff, so they had a butter churn also.

    Food processor > butter churn.

  4. Mimi says:

    Wow, Tricia, I’m loving this! I definitely will try this recipe.

  5. Barbara says:

    Tricia, this looks so easy, plus how could I resist making buttermilk, too! I used to watch my great-grandmother in Louisiana churn butter (no historical reenactment involved) when I was tiny. We’d also have buttermilk over cornbread in the afternoon for a snack. Thanks for taking me on a trip “home”!

Leave a Comment

Let us know your thoughts on this post but remember to place nicely folks!